Erin Foster’s decades-old allegations resurface regarding Chad Michael Murray’s alleged cheating with Sophia Bush. In a recent episode of “The World’s First Podcast” with her sister Sara Foster, Erin Foster revisited a relationship bombshell from the early 2000s. Responding to a DeuxMoi claim, Erin alleged that her ex-boyfriend, Chad Michael Murray, had cheated on her with Sophia Bush back in 2002, during their time living together. Sara backed her sister’s claim, stating, “That is what happened.”
Erin didn’t hold back, confirming the infidelity, saying, “He definitely did cheat on me with her in, like, a pretty egregious way while we were living together.” The 41-year-old actress sarcastically referred to the alleged betrayal as “pretty cool” before lightening the mood with a laugh, adding, “I’ve moved on, though. I’m over it now. I mean, just barely. Just barely over it.”
As of now, neither Chad Michael Murray’s nor Sophia Bush’s representatives have responded to requests for comment from Page Six.
Erin Foster and the actor had dated from 2001 to 2002, and a year after their breakup, Murray publicly began a relationship with Bush. The couple, who had starred together in “One Tree Hill,” became engaged in 2004 and married the following year. However, their marriage was short-lived, ending in divorce in September 2005. Chad Michael Murray then moved on to marry Sarah Roemer in 2015, and they share three children.
Sophia Bush subsequently dated co-star James Lafferty, “Chicago P.D.” actor Jesse Lee Soffer, and businessman Grant Hughes. Bush and Hughes married in June 2022, but she filed for divorce in August of the following year. It was confirmed by Page Six that Bush is now dating newly single soccer star Ashlyn Harris, who filed for divorce from her wife Ali Krieger in September.
Regarding the evolving situation, Hughes’s representative stated that he “is supportive of all that makes [his ex-wife] happy and fulfilled.” While Bush and Harris have yet to comment on their budding romance, there were hints of infidelity in a since-deleted Instagram comment by Kyle Krieger, brother of Ali Krieger, who suggested, “These hoes ain’t loyal.”