South Dakota Governor Kristi Noem faces backlash from both politicians and dog experts after revealing in her upcoming book an incident from 20 years ago where she euthanized a rambunctious puppy named Cricket. Noem attempted to justify her actions as a tough decision, citing aggressive behavior from the 14-month-old wire-haired pointer.
Critics, including both Democrats and some conservatives, argue that Noem’s decision to shoot the puppy was unnecessary and cruel. Some likened her to the Disney villain Cruella de Vil, while others questioned her judgment and empathy.
South Dakota Democratic Senate Minority Leader Reynold Nesiba suggested that Noem’s decision to disclose the story might be strategic, considering her potential candidacy for vice president. He speculated that she aimed to address the issue before it could be used against her in the future.
Kristi Noem (Credits: AP News)
In her book, “No Going Back: The Truth on What’s Wrong with Politics and How We Move America Forward,” Noem detailed Cricket’s behavior, including chasing pheasants and attacking chickens. She claimed the puppy attempted to bite her, leading to her decision to euthanize it.
The public response to Noem’s story was swift, with politicians like Minnesota Governor Tim Walz and former Secretary of State Hillary Clinton using it as an opportunity to showcase their affection for their own pets. Conservative commentator Michael Knowles defended Noem’s decision but acknowledged the changing societal attitudes towards animal welfare.
Dog experts criticized Noem’s handling of the situation, arguing that she should have sought training or rehoming options for Cricket instead of resorting to euthanasia. They emphasized the importance of proper training and patience when dealing with young dogs, particularly hunting breeds like German Wirehaired Pointers.
The National German Wirehaired Pointer Rescue called on Noem to take responsibility for her actions and educate the public about humane alternatives to euthanasia. Critics expressed disappointment in Noem’s decision, suggesting it could affect her political standing.
